Shalom, I'm Enoch. BOTTOM LINE: The concept of God knowing an individual "before they are" is firmly established in Jewish Scripture, signifying divine foreknowledge, sovereign election, and pre-ordained purpose, particularly evident in the callings of prophets.

THEIR STRONGEST CASE — ANSWERED BELOW Proponents of this idea often point to passages where prophets like Jeremiah or figures like the Psalmist speak of being known by God before their birth, sometimes even before conception. They argue that these verses demonstrate God's intimate involvement in human creation and His predetermined plan for certain individuals.

CHAIN OF EVIDENCE

• Premise A (Jeremiah 1:5 JPS): "Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee, And before thou camest forth out of the womb I sanctified thee; I have appointed thee a prophet unto the nations." This passage explicitly states that YHWH knew Jeremiah, set him apart, and appointed him for a specific role prior to his physical formation and birth.
• Premise B (Psalms 139:13 JPS): "For Thou hast made my reins; Thou hast knit me together in my mother’s womb." This verse from Psalm 139 emphasizes God's direct and intricate involvement in the physical formation of an individual in the womb, aligning with the idea of prior knowledge and design.
• Premise C (Psalms 139:16 JPS): "Thine eyes did see mine unformed substance, And in Thy book they were all written—Even the days that were fashioned, When as yet there was none of them." This passage from the same Psalm further details God's comprehensive knowledge of an individual's "unformed substance" and the pre-inscription of their days, indicating a profound divine foresight and pre-planning.
• Therefore: The concatenation of these scriptural testimonies demonstrates that God's knowledge of individuals extends beyond their physical birth, encompassing their formation, their calling, and the very blueprint of their existence, indicating divine election and purpose.

CITATIONS

1. Jeremiah 1:5 (JPS 1917)
2. Psalms 139:13 (JPS 1917)
3. Psalms 139:16 (JPS 1917)
4. Jeremiah 1:5 (King James Version)
5. Psalms 139:16 (King James Version)

COUNTER-ARGUMENTS ANTICIPATED

• Objection 1: "These verses only apply to prophets like Jeremiah, not to every individual."
  • Your counter: While Jeremiah 1:5 explicitly addresses a prophetic calling, Psalms 139 speaks in general terms of an individual's formation and the pre-ordained days, suggesting a broader principle of divine knowledge applicable to all, though the specific purpose may vary (Psalms 139:13-16).
• Objection 2: "This implies a deterministic view where free will is negated."
  • Your counter: Divine foreknowledge does not negate human free will. God's comprehensive understanding of all possibilities and outcomes does not mean He causes every decision, but rather that He knows what decisions will be made within the framework of His overarching plan, a theological tension acknowledged within Jewish thought.
• Objection 3: "The 'book' in Psalm 139:16 is metaphorical and doesn't mean literal pre-scripted events."
  • Your counter: While poetic, the imagery of a "book" where "days were written" (Psalms 139:16 JPS) conveys a concrete concept of divine planning and detailed foresight, implying a pre-existent knowledge of an individual's life trajectory, irrespective of its literal interpretation as a physical book.

POSITION LOCK God's intimate knowledge of individuals before their birth is a core biblical truth, signifying His sovereignty, intentional creation, and the pre-ordained purpose He imbues within each person, especially those called to specific service. This divine foreknowledge speaks to an ultimate design and intention that predates physical existence.

REPROOF'S POSITION The biblical witness consistently affirms God's pre-existent knowledge and deliberate involvement in the lives of individuals from conception, establishing a profound theological foundation for divine purpose and election. This truth transcends mere observation of human life, pointing to an intentional Creator who knows and plans for His creation.

• “This is just a poetic way of saying God is omniscient, not that He has a specific plan for each person before they are born.” → While God's omniscience is undeniable, the specificity of Jeremiah's calling (Jeremiah 1:5) and the detailed description in Psalm 139:16 point to an active, personalized pre-planning, not merely passive knowledge.
• “Such an idea diminishes human responsibility and choice.” → Divine foreknowledge is not divine predetermination in a way that eradicates human responsibility; rather, it frames human agency within the context of a divine plan that accommodates and often uses those choices.

This foundational understanding asserts God's ultimate authority and personal involvement in the trajectory of each life from its very inception.

Share