Tanakh Prophecy
"Until Mashiach the Prince… the rulers against the LORD and His Anointed."
Fulfillment
"We have found the Messias — the Christ."
Rabbinic Sources
"The Mashiach is the central figure of Jewish eschatological expectation."
Deep Dive: The Anointed One (Mashiach)
Historical Context
The prophecy concerning the "Anointed One" (Mashiach) is found in the book of Daniel, which was written during the Babylonian exile in the 6th century BCE. Daniel, a Jewish exile in Babylon, authored this text around 530 BCE, addressing the Jewish people who were grappling with their identity and faith amidst foreign domination. The context of this period is crucial: the Jewish nation was experiencing profound challenges, including the destruction of the First Temple in 586 BCE and the subsequent exile, which left them yearning for restoration and divine intervention.
Daniel's prophecy in 9:25-26 specifically refers to the arrival of the Mashiach as a pivotal figure who would signal a significant transition for Israel. Additionally, Psalm 2:2 refers to the opposition against the LORD's Anointed, emphasizing the conflict between divine authority and earthly powers. Archaeological findings, such as the Dead Sea Scrolls, which include copies of Daniel, underscore the deep messianic expectations held by the Jewish community during the Second Temple period.
Textual Analysis
The Hebrew term "Mashiach" (מָשִׁיחַ) translates to "Anointed One" and signifies a divinely chosen leader. The root of the word, "mashach" (מָשַׁח), means "to anoint," typically with oil, symbolizing the conferment of authority and holiness. In Daniel 9:25, the phrase "Mashiach the Prince" (מָשִׁיחַ נָגִיד) indicates a leader of substantial significance, suggesting not only a political figure but also one with a spiritual mandate.
The translation nuances are noteworthy. For example, the term "Prince" can also be rendered as "leader" or "commander," reflecting the multifaceted role of the Mashiach. Various translations, such as the New King James Version (NKJV) and the Jewish Publication Society (JPS), maintain consistency in the use of "Anointed One," while the New International Version (NIV) opts for "anointed ruler," which highlights the leadership aspect over the purely royal implication.
In Psalm 2:2, the phrase "His Anointed" (מְשִׁיחוֹ) further solidifies the connection between the kingship of Israel and divine purpose, indicating that the Anointed One is not merely a political figure but one endowed with divine authority.
Fulfillment Evidence
The New Testament presents Yeshua as the fulfillment of the Mashiach prophecy. In John 1:41, the disciples declare, "We have found the Messias (the Christ)," directly linking Yeshua to the messianic expectation articulated in the Hebrew Scriptures. Additionally, Acts 4:26 cites the opposition against the LORD and His Anointed, reinforcing the belief that Yeshua embodies the figure prophesied in the Tanakh.
Historical evidence also supports Yeshua's messianic identity. His life, death, and resurrection align with the expectations set forth in Daniel and Psalm 2. Yeshua's crucifixion, often seen as a moment of defeat, is paradoxically a fulfillment of the suffering servant motif found in Isaiah, portraying the Mashiach as one who suffers for the sins of many.
Common objections to Yeshua's messianic claim often center on the expectation of a political deliverer. However, the broader scope of messianic prophecy encompasses both spiritual and political dimensions. Yeshua's teachings and actions reflect a transformative vision of the Kingdom of God that transcends earthly governance.
Rabbinic Perspectives
Traditional rabbinic interpretations, particularly those found in the Talmud (Sanhedrin 97-99), underscore the significance of the Mashiach in Jewish eschatological thought. The Talmud articulates various characteristics of the Mashiach, including his role in restoring Israel and bringing peace. Rabbinic literature acknowledges the expectation of a figure who would lead the Jewish people towards redemption, reinforcing the belief in a coming Mashiach.
Moreover, Midrashic texts often expand upon the Messianic role, depicting the Mashiach as a central figure in the eschatological narrative, which includes the resurrection of the dead and the ultimate reconciliation of Israel with God. The Targumim, Aramaic translations of the Hebrew Scriptures, also reflect a messianic interpretation, particularly in their emphasis on the anointing and divine appointment of the Mashiach.
Significance for Today
The prophecy of the Anointed One remains profoundly relevant for contemporary believers and seekers. The messianic narrative, which spans both the Tanakh and the New Testament, offers a comprehensive understanding of hope, redemption, and divine purpose. For modern readers, the identity of Yeshua as the Mashiach provides assurance of God's ongoing engagement with humanity and the promise of ultimate restoration.
This prophecy encourages believers to reflect on their role in the unfolding messianic vision, emphasizing active participation in justice, compassion, and community building. As such, the concept of the Mashiach transcends historical context, inviting modern individuals to embrace a transformative faith that aligns with the broader messianic hope shared across both Jewish and Christian traditions.
Two Millennia of Adversary Positions
5 eras of objections to this prophecy, with primary sources and Messianic corrections.
Rashi (Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki)
Daniel 9's 'Anointed Prince' is Cyrus the Great
"Until an anointed prince: Cyrus, who was anointed, for God called him, 'My shepherd' (Isa. 44:28) and 'My anointed' (Isa. 45:1), and he was a prince, for he gave the order to build."
Rashi identifies the 'Mashiach the Prince' (מָשִׁיחַ נָגִיד) in Daniel 9:25 not as a future eschatological Messiah, but as the historical Persian king, Cyrus the Great. He bases this on Cyrus being called God's 'anointed' in Isaiah 45:1 and his role in decreeing the rebuilding of the Temple.
Abraham Ibn Ezra
Psalm 2's 'Anointed' Refers Historically to King David
"Against the Lord and against His anointed. They have taken counsel against the Lord, who chose David, and against His anointed, who is David."
Ibn Ezra interprets Psalm 2 as referring historically to King David. He argues that the 'rulers' who 'take counsel together' are the neighboring kings who opposed David, and the 'Anointed' (Mashiach) against whom they conspire is David himself, whom God chose and established as king over Israel.
Isaac Troki
Daniel's 'Anointed One' is Zerubbabel or Cyrus
"The personage here alluded to is Zerubbabel, who, on account of his royal descent from David, is called Messiah Nagid (the Anointed Prince)... Or it may be applied to Cyrus, who is called in Isaiah (xlv. 1) the Anointed of the Lord..."
In his polemical work 'Chizzuk Emunah,' Isaac Troki argues that the 'Anointed Prince' of Daniel 9:25 is a historical figure from the Second Temple period, not a future Messiah. He proposes either Zerubbabel, due to his Davidic descent, or Cyrus, who was called 'anointed' in Isaiah 45:1, as the intended referent.
Tovia Singer
'Mashiach' is a Generic Term, Not a Title for 'The Messiah'
"The Hebrew word mashiach appears 39 times in the Jewish scriptures. In 38 instances, Christian translators rendered the word mashiach as 'anointed.' In just one case, Daniel 9:25, they translated it as 'Messiah.' This is a glaring inconsistency."
Tovia Singer argues that the Hebrew word 'mashiach' simply means 'anointed' and refers to any individual consecrated for a specific purpose, such as a king, high priest, or even the Persian king Cyrus. He contends that Christian translations are inconsistent, rendering 'mashiach' as 'anointed' in 38 instances but as 'Messiah' in Daniel 9:25 to support their theology.
Chabad.org
'Moshiach' Simply Means 'Anointed' Like Ancient Kings and Priests
"The word 'Moshiach' means 'anointed.' The Jewish Bible relates that in ancient times, kings, high priests and prophets were anointed with oil when they were appointed to their respective offices. For example, when Samuel appointed Saul the first king of Israel, he 'took the vial of oil, and poured it upon his head' (I Samuel 10:1)."
Chabad.org explains that 'Moshiach' (Mashiach) literally means 'anointed' and was a title applied to kings, high priests, and prophets who were anointed with oil for their office. This is used to frame the Jewish concept of a future Messiah as a human king who will be appointed in a similar manner, while distinguishing this from the Christian conception of a divine savior.